I went to see Michelle Shocked on Saturday night.
Now, I'm a bit of a fan. We're not talking one of those dyed in the wool fans who have her every album, and have actually been to see her before, you understand, just a modest fan who enjoys the single album she owns. The album she, in actual fact, stole from a previous boyfriend, who introduced her to Michelle Shocked.
Now we've established my level of fandom, let's move along to the concert. I have to confess to being a little disappointed. Just a little.
You see, Michelle came on stage over 15 minutes late, to tell us that she wasn't going to be playing straight away, but that her band would be playing for about 20 minutes first. Oh, OK. She then went on to tell us that people had complained about the fact that she tended to be a bit chatty. This didn't bother me, because I quite like an artist to have a little bit of a chat with us between songs - it helps engage the audience. She proceeded to tell us that she was going to carry on with the whole chatty thing, and wasn't going to listen to her detractors (or producers), and she'd carry on with the chattiness, regardless. Well, OK. Then what she said next sort of annoyed me. She said that if she saw anyone recording her gig, she'd come in the audience and deal with the person. She proceeded to ask us to NOT record the gig, and tried to be jokey about it, saying that what happened in Aldershot should stay in Aldershot. She then went off on a rant about how anyone of us who'd ever copied one of her CD's for a friend or downloaded any of her tracks off the internet without paying for it should feel seriously ashamed. I felt this was somewhat ironic, given how she
started out.
It's not even, you understand, that I'm against paying for music. I've downloaded, illegally, exactly 5 tracks in my time, of which I've subsequently purchased the album for 3 of them, and the track for one. The 5th - sorry. I just didn't get round to it. If I can get my stuff legally, I'll do it. I've even started to buy MP3 albums from Amazon.co.uk, and download them. I suspect many who know what a tech-head I am will be surprised to find that I've only actually bought 2 MP3 albums (the aforementioned 3 albums were purchased as actual CDs), and both of those since May this year. How can I pin it down to May so easily? 3 words - Eurovision Song Contest! And my copy of Short, Sharp, Shocked is legit, too.
So the band started, introducing themselves as a mandolin player from Ireland, a banjo player from America, and a fiddler from Italy. They were all very good, and the music was upbeat and enjoyable. They'd not been working together for long, and although you could see that, it didn't matter. I think it added a bit of freshness to the performance. They were clearly enjoying not only the playing, but each other's company. The music was a little country. It's possible it might even have been described as bluegrass, but I don't really know my American country music, so I'm not sure about that.
And finally, three quarters of an hour after the supposed start time of the gig, Michelle came on and started playing. It was nice that she was playing alone, because that's how I'd first heard her.
But, oh dear. Now there are many artists who understand what it is that the fans want. You and I, as fans of a band, we know what we want. We want to hear the songs as close to the version on the album as is humanly possible. This is where many tribute bands do so well. When the real bands have either died, split up, given up or just plain don't want to do it any more, the tribute bands play the songs the fans want to hear, in the way the fans want to hear them. Michelle didn't. She started with one of my favourites from the Short, Sharp, Shocked album, When I Grow Up. Which has a lovely, bluesy guitar running through it. Bluesy guitar - check. Singing same as album version - nope! I do get that it must be really boring, artistically to have to sing the same thing, the same way, every damn gig, but I'd enthused my mum into going with me by telling her all about it, and how much she was going to enjoy it. Well, it was OK, but not quite what I'd expected. Thankfully the next song, Memories of East Texas, is a pleasant ballad, and was sung in a way very similar to the album.
But this is where, to my intense dismay, Michelle wanted us to sing. Now here's the deal. I don't sing in public. I just don't. Well, I'll sing if the music is belting out loudly enough to drown me out so that no one, just no one, can hear how badly I hold a tune (and indeed, did just that at the earlier Lady Gaga concert). I have no pretence to being a singer. I'm probably not the worst singer on the face of the planet, but I'm by no means the best. I'll sing on the rare occasions you may persuade me into church, and I'll belt it out, because I have no sympathy there, but at a quiet, intimate gig like this one, there was no way I was going to sing. Mum leaned over sympathetically to say "Don't know the words, eh? We seem to be surrounded by some serious fans!" to which I just replied that I do know the words, I DON'T, however, sing in public. Leave that to those who are more at home there. Still, a good song, and one of the ones I've always enjoyed from the album.
And then came Graffiti Limbo. Now this is a great song, and shows her somewhat political roots. It took me a beat or two to recognise what we were listening to, because she was singing it, again, differently from the album, but actually it was sounding pretty good. That is until the middle of the song. Now, on the Album version she goes on to explain that the song was written for Michael Stewart, a young, black graffiti artist who was arrested while writing graffiti on the New York subway. This is not only fine and good, it's a concise explanation of the song, and detracts nothing from the singing. This time, however, Michelle went off on one. And by one, I mean a number of political rants including one on our own government. Now, as my sister in law once said, "We know Milosevic is a bastard, but he's OUR bastard!", which is pretty much how I feel about our government. While the current coalition may not be the best possible solution, it's actually a deal better than another term of Labour, and anyway, we've had it in place for a very short time - I'm prepared to give them the benefit of the doubt, and let them work on reducing our appalling debt. What I'm not prepared to do is accept an outsider's opinion on our government when she seems to know little about the situation. I have to say that this put a serious downer on my enjoyment for quite some time.
And then we got to the last song of the ones I knew, The L&N don't stop here any more. This is actually quite a depressing song, but it's a good melody, with another lovely blues riff running through it. This was a whole lot more enjoyable, until we were exhorted, once again, to sing, sing, SING! Oh god! Anyway, I really don't know the
words to this song, which seemed to go on for EVER! First we were all encouraged to sing, dirge like, the chorus. Then the ladies, then the gentlemen, then all together again. I say dirge like, because it's really not the most upbeat chorus on the face of the planet (pop over to
grooveshark and have a listen - I don't know if that link will work). Although the version on the album (and, indeed, the grooveshark version) is actually quite a chipper little number, "we" were singing it way slower than it should be sung, and it sounded like a bunch of school kids greeting their headmaster!
At this point we switched to another album, Arkansas Traveller, which is not an album I know. This not-knowing could well have been a blessing in disguise, as I was unable to say that I didn't like any of these tracks. In fact, apart from her going off in the middle of the tracks, these were a lot more upbeat. She was now singing with the rest of the group, and, again, the melodies were lovely. At the end, for the encore, she played us a new track she hasn't even released yet. Now the song was lovely. However, the attendant, by now annoying, political ranting very nearly ruined it for me, because the song's about Anne Frank. Well, it's about a painting of Anne Frank done by Michelle's partner, and how it hangs in her flat, and is Always There. This was actually the chirpiest song of the whole evening, and I'd have enjoyed it a whole lot more if we hadn't been exhorted, once again, to sing! Oh dear GOD!
I hate to say it, but it was almost a relief that the concert ended there.
Now, as I mentioned, many bands know exactly what to do to make their fans happy. Usually they're on tour to promote a new album, which may or may not have been heard yet, but sure as anything the fans are there because they've enjoyed songs from the band previously. And so the bands will usually play a good mix of their earlier stuff (in the way expected by the fans), along with most of the songs on the new album.
Michelle even made a comment to the effect that one of the people viewing one of her previous gigs had told her she should sing the song as it was on the album, to which she replied, "Well I guess y'all prolly know the song better'n me, so I'll just go ahead and sing it how I want to." I'm not sure this is the statement of a person in complete accord with her fans.
Today, before this computer, sits a shaken fan. I'd say shocked, but you might hate me for the pun!